今天也算双喜临门了，会议报告圆满结束+第一篇sci终于接收了

文章接收

这篇sci的接收之路真是坎坷，尽管文章总数比不上zsl师兄，但拒稿数已经能够比肩了……

一开始投给pof，pof虽然近几年因为审稿过程不尊重审稿人、审稿质量也参差不齐，口碑下滑得厉害，但还算是流体专业有分量的期刊，中科院二区top。确实审稿飞快，可是我只收到一个人的审稿意见，很负面，但是他提的问题就仿佛没看完文章。我导还帮我写了一份申诉，认为审稿人的意见有失偏颇，下面是我导的原话：

I am writing to you because we think the reviewer's comments are too unfair and irresponsible. The reviewer didn't comment any of the idea and results of our paper, but instead, he/she just gave some ridiculous understandings of the background and certain sentences. We even guess the reviewer didn't read the paper completely.
……

太帅了，赞美我导！但是总之还是被拒稿了，pof对此的回应非常的官方，

I have considered the manuscript, the reviewer comments, both those shared with the author and those shared with the Editor, the reviewer stature, the Editor's decision, and your appeal request, and have decided to affirm the decision not to publish this manuscript in Physics of Fluids. This decision is final, and the manuscript is no longer under consideration for publication in Physics of Fluids.

The problem here is that, for a community journal such as Physics of Fluids, we are not at liberty to publish material that has not satisfied the reviewers. In this case, I see no possibility of satisfying all reviewers. Your option here is to revise thoroughly and submit anew to Physics of Fluids.

后来又转而投了pre和aescte，这两个也拒稿了，都是编辑拒稿，理由是和期刊主题不相符，建议另投。

最后投给了cja，审稿要求盲审，流程很规范，果然还是中国人不骗中国人！可惜cja在中科院top期刊待了一年就掉出来了，现在只是个普通的sci二区。祝她越办越好！

我总共有两个审稿人，一共提出三条意见，改动不多。下面是我的审稿记录：

  • 2023.05.23 submitted to journal
  • 2023.05.24 with editor
  • 2023.05.28 under review
  • 2023.07.05 required reviews completed
  • 2023.07.21 revision submitted to journal
  • 2023.07.21 under review
  • 2023.07.30 required reviews completed
  • 2023.08.03 with editor
  • 2023.08.11 decision in process

会议报告

说起来，其实今天还有一件大事，之前投稿了第17届亚洲流体力学会议，正好今天报告。这里存放一点会议图，另外还有我会议结束后回母校逛了一圈的照片。

会议照片

北航照片

大佬论坛